Beard,+Kyle

I look for the value/value criterion and framework to see if it really applies to your arguments. I am not too strict about evidence, but I am more of a traditional judge and I like to have analysis in the round. It is good to hear a piece of evidence, but I want to know how it applies to your arguments. Although I prefer classic LD debate, as a judge it is my responsibility to treat every round fairly regardless of my preferences but I prefer no spreading during the debates.