Mathur,+Shivani


 * EDIT: I HAVE NOT JUDGED IN A LONG TIME, SO PLEASE GO SLOW**

I debated for Oakwood (not the one in LA) in California.
 * Short Version:**
 * I don't judge often, so I'm not familiar with topic lit
 * It is in your best interest to not go your fastest
 * Theory is not my forte

That is: -I default to competing interps unless told otherwise -I default to drop the arg not the drop the debater -I like to see specific interpretations/violations/whatnot. If you're extemping a theory shell, make it as clear as possible. -I meet with some sort of reason is a perfectly reasonable response to a shell That being said, __if you're a theory debater, I'm not the judge for you.__
 * Speed**: I can handle spreading, but please don’t go full blitz at me. I will yell clear 3 times before I start dropping speaks. Also, if you’re spreading just to scare your opponent //and// refuse to explain your case, I’ll drop speaks.
 * Extensions:** I have a high threshold for extensions, so please extend your arguments fully or I won’t consider them extended.
 * Theory:** I’m not a giant fan of theory, but just because I don’t like it doesn’t mean I won’t vote for it. The way I see it, theory should be run as a check on abuse or somewhat obvious potential abuse. I'm pretty much in tune with the norm on how most people view theory.
 * Skep:** why
 * Kritiks:** I really enjoy kritiks! As long as your prove a clear link to resolution, I’ll be a happy judge.
 * Framework:** I default to a utilitarian worldview if nobody tells me differently. I enjoy engaging framework debates and philosophical discussions. Judging util-deont deadlocks in which each debater is reading generic dumps is not my favorite thing. Make it exciting.
 * Intervention:** I honestly prefer not to intervene. However, I will intervene if neither debater has done enough work to warrant a vote. Also, I won't blindly vote on an unwarranted argument (even if it goes conceded).
 * Speaks:** I won’t give less than a 26 unless your argument was offensive or you were incredibly rude during the round. Most debaters will fall in the 27-29 range.

Lots of weighing is a great way to get my ballot. I believe in voting on the flow. That being said, please be organized as you debate. Few things frustrate me more than debaters who don't signpost or tell me where they're going. Most importantly, have fun! Feel free to ask me any questions