Chen,+Bill

Public Forum, Policy, LD judge Affiliation: Gabrielino High School San Gabriel, CA

HS Public Forum participant for 2 years HS Public Forum judge for 4 years
 * Public Forum:**

- Okay with speed - Cordial in crossfires or I will knock down your speaker points - Very clear voting issues in rebuttals - Need to have clash in ideas. This is PF, not Policy or LD. Evidence and philosophy should be the backbone of the clash, but not at the forefront.

HS Policy participant for 3 years HS Policy judge for 4 years
 * Policy**:

- Not a fan of topicality but if it is relevant and is not addressed, will become voting issue. - Unless there is substantive evidence of abuse, I find it a shoddy argument to run. - Okay with Ks, CPs, D/As, etc. - Spreading is fine with me, but if I can't hear it, then I can't hear it. - Voting issues need to be signposted in last rebuttal. - Impact analysis very key

HS LD judge for 4 years
 * LD:**

- Big fan of the value/value criterion debate - Not too big on evidence in LD- keep it about the philosophy - Okay with speech - Last speech must lay out voters