Hirth,+Phyllis

I expect the debaters to present their arguments in a clear and understandable manner. Clarity and communication to the judge is paramount. I also expect each speaker to address the topic. Give me a criteria on which you want me to judge the round and Value premise is necessary in a values debate. I do not like critiques or definitional debates and enjoy a round with good, clear cut clash. I have been a coach and judge for 25 years. At present I do not coach but I do judge several times a year.